In Kozhani v. Jevco Insurance, 2026 ONSC 5286, released September 8, 2026, the Ontario Divisional Court addressed an important procedural issue for parties seeking to appeal a decision of the Licence Appeal Tribunal (“LAT”): Does requesting reconsideration of a LAT decision extend or restart the time to appeal that decision to the Divisional Court?
The Court confirmed it does not.
Kozhani establishes that where an appeal, in substance, challenges the LAT’s underlying decision on the merits, the appeal period runs from the date of that merits decision. A party therefore cannot rely on the reconsideration process to suspend, extend, or revive the appeal period.
Background
The underlying LAT proceeding concerned the Applicant’s claim for a catastrophic impairment designation.
On March 6, 2025, the LAT determined that the Applicant had not established catastrophic impairment. The Applicant subsequently requested reconsideration on March 27, 2025, alleging procedural unfairness and errors of fact and errors of law. There was no application for judicial review.
The LAT dismissed the reconsideration request on July 2, 2025.
On August 1, 2025, the Applicant appealed to the Divisional Court, identifying the July 2, 2025 reconsideration decision as the decision under appeal. However, the grounds advanced were directed primarily at the LAT’s original findings on the merits, including its treatment of the evidence, assessment of impairment, rejection of expert opinion evidence, and the alleged procedural unfairness in the conduct of the merits hearing.
The insurer raised a preliminary objection, arguing that the appeal was out of time because the Applicant was, in substance, appealing the March 6, 2025 merits decision.
The Court Looks to the Substance of the Appeal
The Divisional Court ultimately agreed with the insurer. The Court emphasized that the characterization of an appeal does not depend solely on which decision is identified in the Notice of Appeal. Rather, the Court must examine the “true substance” of the grounds advanced.
In this case, the Applicant’s grounds were directed at the findings made in the March 6, 2025 merits decision. The reconsideration decision did not rehear or redetermine the catastrophic impairment issue. Instead, it considered whether the threshold for reconsideration had been met. Accordingly, the Court concluded that the Applicant was, in substance, appealing the original merits decision.
Reconsideration Does Not Suspend or Restart the Appeal Period
In reaching its conclusion, the Court relied on its earlier decision in Rao v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, 2024 ONSC 39 (CanLII).
The Court reiterated that the statutory right of appeal arises from the LAT’s final merits determination. A request for reconsideration does not postpone, suspend or restart the appeal period, nor does a subsequent reconsideration decision revive an appeal right that has already expired.
The Court rejected the argument that a party must await the outcome of the LAT’s internal reconsideration process before commencing an appeal.
While administrative law principles generally favour exhausting available internal remedies before seeking judicial intervention, the Court distinguished those principles from the need to preserve a statutory right of appeal,
- [31] The difficulty with the appellant’s position is that it conflates two distinct concepts: exhaustion of administrative remedies and preservation of statutory appellate rights. Volochay and Cura stand for the proposition that available administrative remedies should usually be pursued before the court intervenes. They do not hold that pursuing an internal reconsideration process suspends a statutory appeal deadline; nor do they suggest that a party who lets a statutory appeal period expire may revive that right through a later reconsideration decision.
Pursuing reconsideration does not alter an otherwise applicable appeal deadline.
Importantly, the Court confirmed that the two processes can coexist. Where a party wishes to pursue reconsideration while also preserving an appeal, the prudent course is to commence the appeal within the applicable appeal period and advise the Court that a reconsideration request remains outstanding. The appeal may then be held in abeyance while the LAT determines the reconsideration request.
The LAT released its merits decision on March 6, 2025. The Applicant did not commence the appeal until August 1, 2025, well outside the applicable 30-day appeal period. The Court therefore quashed the appeal as out of time.
The order was made without prejudice to the Applicant’s ability to bring a motion seeking an extension of time to appeal.
Key Takeaway
Kozhani provides an important warning that a reconsideration request should not be treated as stopping the appeal clock.
Where a party intends to challenge a LAT merits decision on a question of law, the appeal deadline should be calculated from the merits decision itself. If reconsideration is also being pursued, the safer course is to preserve the statutory appeal within the applicable deadline and seek to have the appeal held in abeyance pending the outcome of reconsideration.
Kozhani also confirms that simply identifying a reconsideration decision in a Notice of Appeal will not avoid an expired appeal period. The Divisional Court will examine the substance of the grounds of appeal to determine which decision is truly being challenged.
For insurers and counsel handling LAT matters, the practical message is straightforward: where both reconsideration and an appeal are contemplated, preserve the appeal first.
Elisa Prezzano is a member of the Appellate Advocacy group at ZTGH and author of this blog. If you have a question about this decision, please reach out to Elisa at [email protected].